First of all, if you haven’t yet seen it …
This was a very good couple of days for me, and the premature arrival of this trailer played no small role in that fact! I am very excited for this film and all it portends, but that doesn’t mean I can’t remain objective about it. There are some things to gush over, there are some concerns. Humor me as I expound …
1. The Tone – I like the tone. Batman appears menacing, society seems both enamored with and distrustful of Superman, and everything looks cinematic. The music is brooding yet epic. I’m sure the movie will be as well. If nothing else, visually speaking, it’s beautiful.
2. False God – As stated above, I very much think our present day society would have a field day with Superman if he truly existed. We love our larger-than-life figures, and you can’t get bigger than Superman. I have no doubt our celebrity culture would deify him, and this looks to be the case according to the statue. However, as is so often the case, we always tear down our celebrity heroes, it’s only a matter of time. Again, the graffiti scrolled across the statue would suggest as such. Superman appears to be no exception to our base behavior.
3. Kneel Before Superman – But what if he’s more than just a celebrity? I’ll be honest, Superman looks pretty malicious in this trailer, and when the soldiers dropped to a knee before him, I saw shades of the book and video game called Injustice. Could this be a world where Superman has sworn something awful like Zod can never happen again? Has he lost his sense of justice and become a world enforcer? I can’t imagine that’s the Superman they want to build a franchise around. I’m still troubled by the role he played in the decimation of Metropolis a few years ago. To be fair, though, it could make him psychologically more interesting …
4. The Voice – I like the armored Batman voice. It’s gravely, yet metallic. It effectively hides Bruce Wayne’s real voice, as one would expect in the real world. Is it the same voice even when Batman isn’t armored up? Only time will tell.
5. Dark Knight Returns Returns – The armored Batman calling out Superman on the street … straight out of The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller. This is a good thing. I can’t imagine the movie will end as did the book, but the mere fact they are paying homage to such an iconic moment … it’s thrilling.
I’m glad you’re looking forward to this. Sadly, I’m remain unconvinced about Snyder as a creative talent. His track record is full of films that have had really good aspects – but also films with huge flaws. Hope I’m wrong. Great piece, by the way. You almost convinced me to look forward to this one.